The Paris 2024 Olympic Games have become embroiled in controversy, centering on the sport of boxing and the participation of Algerian boxer Imane Khelif. Khelif’s inclusion in the women’s division, despite not passing the gender identity tests prior to the event, has ignited a heated debate across social media and beyond. Her participation culminated in a shocking victory, which has left the boxing community and international spectators divided.
On Thursday morning, Khelif faced Italian boxer Angela Carini in a match that lasted less than a minute. The bout ended abruptly when Carini, after receiving a powerful right blow to the head, decided to abandon the fight, securing Khelif a swift and decisive victory. This outcome has sparked widespread criticism and debate, particularly in Italy, where questions about Khelif’s eligibility have taken center stage.
The controversy surrounding Khelif’s participation began with her pre-Olympic medical tests, which revealed high levels of testosterone and an XY chromosome. These findings have led many to question her suitability to compete in the women’s category. However, it is important to note that Khelif is not a transsexual athlete; rather, she has a condition known as hyperandrogenism, which results in higher levels of testosterone and a more masculine appearance.
Adding fuel to the controversy are the remarks of Mexican boxer Brianda Tamara Cruz, who faced Khelif at the Golden Belt Series Finals in Guadalajara in late 2022. Cruz described the experience as being unlike any other in her 13-year boxing career. “When I fought her, I felt very out of my league; her punches hurt me a lot. Never in my 13 years as a boxer had I felt like that, not even in my sparring with men. Thank God, that day I got out of the ring safely and it’s good that they finally noticed it,” Cruz said.
These comments, originally shared on Cruz’s social media after Khelif’s disqualification from the 2023 Amateur World Championships, highlight the ongoing debate about fairness and competition integrity. The International Boxing Association had previously disqualified several athletes, including Khelif, for attempting to deceive their opponents by posing as women.
The controversy extends beyond Khelif, as Taiwanese boxer Lin Yu-ting, who is set to debut at Paris 2024 on Friday, faces similar scrutiny. Both athletes have been at the center of intense discussions regarding their eligibility to compete in the women’s category, given the test results indicating elevated testosterone levels and, in Khelif’s case, the presence of a male chromosome. Despite these findings, the International Olympic Committee has upheld their participation in the Games.
The debate over Khelif’s and Lin Yu-ting’s participation underscores the pressing need for a reevaluation of eligibility criteria to ensure fair and equitable competition in boxing and other sports. As the Paris 2024 Olympics continue, this controversy serves as a reminder of the complex intersection of gender, biology, and sportsmanship on the world stage. The outcome of this debate could have far-reaching implications for the future of women’s sports and the standards by which athletes are assessed and classified.
